I doubt you're all out wearing your Effie makeup from yesterday, but here's a way you can go out in public wearing Effie without ending up on People of Walmart.
I used the same colors from the Effie Trinket tutorial, just in an everyday look.
Eyeshadow, Vibrant Grape
Mascara, False Lashes
Blush, Coy Girl
Kissable Lip Color, Enchantee